Skip to main content

Roman J. Israel, Esq. (2017), PG-13, ★★


We do not get many legal movies as much right now compared to the 1990s and early 2000s. I mean, there were some great, good and some rather pedestrian legal dramas. Maybe, it is because almost all of the legal/courtroom thrillers end in the same way but the movie is really about the journey and the case. Also, movies in the 90s were being adapted from novels written by John Grisham: The Pelican Brief, The Firm, A Time to Kill and The Rainmaker. However, this movie was different as it is about a lawyer wanting to do the right thing by doing pro bono work and "not work for the ungrateful". It has a positive and uplifting spin to an old-fashioned genre but somehow the movie starts to lose heart and conviction as the character loses heart as suspense starts to increase towards the end.

Roman J. Israel (Denzel Washington) is an attorney working at his desk in a legal office as he gets a call from his secretary that his law partner had a heart attack, persuading him to work on all the cases. But, his secretary suggests to Roman that he should give continuances due to the health emergency. But, Roman does not listen as he goes to court and lobbying by lowering the charges for prosecution. He also gets into an argument with the judge that resulted in him getting a $5,000 fine. 

Roman was very active in the civil rights era in the 60s and his law firm was very instrumental as well and it's noticeable as helps a homeless man off the street by putting a business card in his pocket as the police are taking him away. A woman named Maya (Carmen Ejogo) is impressed as she invited him earlier into a session of giving protestors legal advice. Another attorney, George Pierce (Colin Farell) offers Roman a job after finding out that he has numerous clients over the years that want his help. But when he gets the job, Roman has gotten himself with a situation in which a man has been accused of murder according to a young man which leads to a potential $100,000 reward for information. However, there are risks as the deal will threaten both Roman's career and life.


There are two kinds of movies in this that is executed well but the other plot is executed poorly. The character of Roman J. Israel is inspiring because he wants to help people and not help the corrupt or the greedy. There is a nice story underneath between the Roman and Maya chemistry that unfortunately does not go anywhere. Now, with the other story involving the murder case, it tonally becomes awkward because of its poor execution then it becomes self-indulgent as he improves his image. Also, even though the costume design and physical appearance is noticeable, the character development set-up takes too long because the "thriller" plot becomes rushed as there are scenes missing or needed some re-organization. 

Denzel Washington's performance is good, not one of his best, though, because at times, even though I root for his character in some of the movie, he does get annoying with all the clothes as he is trapped in the times of the 60s and 70s in a present time. It is too obvious and a bit distracting as the character's appearance is over-the-top. Two characters are underwritten with Carmen Ejogo giving a very nice performance and Colin Farell in a really strong role but there are not many scenes in which I actually remember the character as he wants to help Roman with his case. 

I was mostly disappointed because it was directed by Dan Gilroy, the man who gave us one of the best movies of 2014, Nightcrawler, with an excellent performance by Jake Gyllenhaal, who should have gotten nominated that year. I do like its setting that this whole movie is taken place in Los Angeles making a very mysterious and maybe deceiving location in where the character is going, however, the tonal shift to its thriller ruins it as the conclusion of the plot is predictable. But, by not giving it away, the end felt like it was not completely finished. There is promise to its story, setting, message and characters in the first half, however, the movie lets go by giving us a convoluted thriller that felt a bit sloppy. And, that is unfortunate because I wanted to like this movie for its message.

**


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Handmaiden (2016), Unrated, ★★★1/2

What are you up to? Huh? I heard some praise from a few people I know that have seen this film and I was a bit skeptical because unfortunately I do not get the chance to see many foreign films. This movie is based on a British novel that is transposed to a Korean story under a Japanese ruler. I was going into this cold not knowing what the title could lead to or what the story will be about and how this movie will unfold. And, I have to say: Know a little bit of the plot but not much else because the result is a harrowing experience that is twisted, disturbing, erotic, and most of all, classical with such disciplined filmmaking by director Park Chan-Wook. A con man hires a pickpocket named Sook-hee (Kim Tae-ri), who is well-known as she comes from a family of con artists, to become Lady Hideko's (Kim Min-hee) handmaiden. Her mission is to convince Hideko to reject her barbarous uncle, Kouzuki (Cho Jin-Woong) and marry Fujiwara (Ha Jung-Woo), who hired Sook-hee. Kouzuki's

The Best Films of the Year (1999, 2003-2023)

I've posted my lists of the best films over the years, 1999, 2003-2023. You can take a look and glance at them. (Revised on 04/22/2024). 1999 1. The Insider  (Mann) 2. Magnolia  (Anderson) 3. The Matrix  (Wachowskis) 4. Being John Malkovich  (Jonze) 5. Fight Club  (Fincher) 6. The Straight Story  (Lynch) 7. The Talented Mr. Ripley  (Minghella) 8. Eyes Wide Shut  (Kubrick)  9. The Iron Giant  (Bird) 10. American Beauty  (Mendes) 11. The Sixth Sense  (Shyamalan) 12. Topsy-Turvy  (Leigh) 13. Toy Story 2  (Lasseter) 14. All About My Mother  (Almodovar) 15. Galaxy Quest  (Parisot) 2003 1. The Lord of the Rings: The Return of the King  (Jackson) 2. Lost In Translation   (Coppola) 3. Finding Nemo   (Stanton) 4. Mystic River   (Eastwood) 5. Kill Bill Vol. 1   (Tarantino) 6. Master and Commander: The Far Side of the World  (Weir) 7. In America   (Sheridan) 8. Elf   (Favreau) 9. Whale Rider   (Caro) 10. Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl   (Verbinski) 2004 1. Milli

2015 Movie Reviews

I'm not using Blogger as much on the site to post because I felt that I was losing time and viewership. Unfortunately, I do not think people read my reviews as much anymore. So, if you want to catch or watch my movie reviews. For now, visit my Instagram movie profile, @cine_caro. I edit the videos in a minute or less and I give a brief review it as a voiceover and rate them. So, if you want to catch up, here are the movies that I reviewed this year in 2015 and their ratings. 2015 4 STARS Anomalisa **** The Big Short **** The Revenant **** Spotlight **** Brooklyn **** Room **** Steve Jobs **** The Martian **** Sicario **** The End of the Tour **** Me and Earl and the Dying Girl **** Inside Out **** Mad Max: Fury Road *** Ex Machina **** 3.5 STARS Star Wars: The Force Awakens ***1/2 Carol ***1/2 Creed ***1/2 Beasts of No Nation (NETFLIX) ***1/2 Bridge of Spies ***1/2 Goodnight Mommy ***1/2 Straight Outta Compton ***1/2 The Gift ***1/2 Mission Imposs